Are you befuddled by the intricate legal system and find yourself scratching your head when it comes to distinguishing between the High Court and Supreme Court?
The High Court is the highest court at the state or provincial level, with jurisdiction over a specific geographic region, while Supreme Court is the highest court at the national or federal level, with authority over the entire country.
High vs. Supreme Court
| High Court | Supreme Court |
|---|---|
| High Courts are the highest judicial bodies at the state or regional level, with jurisdiction over specific states or union territories within a country. | The Supreme Court is the highest judicial body in a country, with jurisdiction over the entire country and the power to hear and decide appeals from lower courts and constitutional matters. |
| It primarily functions as appellate courts, hearing appeals from lower courts within their respective jurisdiction and reviewing their decisions. | It acts as the final appellate court, hearing appeals from High Courts and other lower courts, ensuring uniformity in the interpretation and application of laws across the country. |
| High Courts play a significant role in safeguarding and interpreting the constitution at the state or regional level, protecting fundamental rights and resolving constitutional disputes. | The Supreme Court has a crucial constitutional role, ensuring the protection of fundamental rights, interpreting the constitution, and acting as the guardian of the constitution for the entire country. |
| It have multiple judges, typically consisting of a Chief Justice and several other judges appointed by the President or Governor based on recommendations from the judiciary. | It has a fixed number of judges, including a Chief Justice and a set number of other judges determined by the constitution or legislation governing the functioning of the court. |
| High Courts have the power of judicial review, enabling them to review the constitutionality of laws and executive actions within their respective jurisdiction. | The Supreme Court has extensive powers of judicial review, allowing it to examine the constitutionality of laws, executive actions, and decisions of High Courts and other lower courts throughout the country. |
| It is bound by the decisions and precedents set by the Supreme Court and are expected to follow the principles and interpretations established by the Supreme Court. | It is the ultimate authority on legal interpretations, and its decisions and precedents serve as binding and authoritative guidelines for all other courts, including High Courts. |
Overview of High Court and Supreme Court
The High Court is a court of superior jurisdiction within a specific state or province. It is typically the highest court in that particular jurisdiction and has authority over matters pertaining to that state or province. The High Court is responsible for interpreting and applying the laws of that jurisdiction and ensuring justice is served.
The Supreme Court is the highest court in a country or a federal system. It has the ultimate authority in interpreting and applying the Constitution and federal laws. The Supreme Court typically has the power to review decisions made by lower courts and has the final say on legal matters of national importance. Its rulings set precedents that lower courts must follow.
Jurisdiction of the High Court and Supreme Court
The High Courts have original jurisdiction in respect of criminal and civil matters arising within their territorial limits. In addition, they also have appellate jurisdiction in respect of decisions rendered by subordinate courts situated within their territories.
The Supreme Court has exclusive jurisdiction in respect of matters that involve the interpretation of the Constitution. It also has appellate jurisdiction in respect of decisions rendered by High Courts as well as other subordinate courts.
In addition to its appellate and constitutional jurisdiction, the Supreme Court also has original jurisdiction in case of disputes between two or more states or between the Union government and one or more states. It also acts as a court of record and has powers to issue various types of writs for enforcement of Fundamental Rights guaranteed under the Constitution.
How are judges appointed in both High Courts and Supreme Courts?
The process for appointing judges to the High Court is set out in Article 125 of the Constitution. The President shall appoint judges to the High Court on the advice of the Prime Minister. The President may also consult with such other persons as he may deem fit for this purpose.
The process for appointing judges to the Supreme Court is set out in Article 124 of the Constitution. The President shall appoint judges to the Supreme Court on the advice of the Chief Justice. The President may also consult with such other persons as he may deem fit for this purpose.
Powers of High Courts and Supreme Courts
Powers of High Courts:
- Original Jurisdiction: High Courts have the power to hear and decide certain types of cases directly, without them being first heard by lower courts.
- Appellate Jurisdiction: High Courts have the power to hear appeals from lower courts within their jurisdiction. They can review the decisions of lower courts and either uphold, modify, or reverse those decisions.
- Writ Jurisdiction: High Courts have the power to issue writs, such as writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, certiorari, prohibition, and quo warranto, to safeguard fundamental rights and ensure the proper functioning of the legal system.
Powers of Supreme Courts:
- Constitutional Interpretation: The Supreme Court has the ultimate authority in interpreting the Constitution and determining the constitutionality of laws and government actions.
- Appellate Jurisdiction: The Supreme Court serves as the final court of appeal, hearing cases that have been appealed from lower courts. It has the power to review and overturn decisions made by lower courts.
- Judicial Review: The Supreme Court has the power of judicial review over laws and government actions to ensure their conformity with the Constitution.
Judicial review
The Constitution gives the Supreme Court explicit power to exercise judicial review. In Marbury v. Madison, Chief Justice John Marshall wrote that “it is emphatically the province and duty of the Judicial Department to say what the law is.”
This power flows from Article III of the Constitution, which establishes the judiciary as a co-equal branch of government tasked with interpreting and applying the law. As such, when Congress passes a law that conflicts with the Constitution, it is up to the Supreme Court to invalidate that law.
The High Court, however, does not have this explicit power. In Australia’s system of government, there is no equivalent to America’s Constitution. As a result, the High Court cannot strike down laws passed by Parliament; its role is limited to interpreting and applying them.
Key differences between High and Supreme Court
- Jurisdiction: High Courts have jurisdiction over a specific state or province, whereas the Supreme Court has jurisdiction at the national or federal level. The High Court deals with matters within its state or provincial boundaries, while the Supreme Court handles cases of national importance.
- Hierarchy: High Courts are subordinate to the Supreme Court. They operate at a lower level in the judicial hierarchy, and their decisions can be appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court is the highest judicial authority in the country or federal system and has the final say in legal matters.
- Appellate Jurisdiction: High Courts primarily function as appellate courts, hearing appeals from lower courts within their jurisdiction. The Supreme Court also has appellate jurisdiction, but it serves as the final court of appeal, hearing cases that have been appealed by lower courts and High Courts.
- Difference between IAS and IPS
- Difference between Cognizable and Non-Cognizable Offences
- Difference between Complaint and FIR
Conclusion
The High Court operates at the state or provincial level with jurisdiction limited to a specific region, while the Supreme Court has jurisdiction at the national or federal level. The Supreme Court serves as the final court of appeal and has the ultimate authority in interpreting the constitution. It handles cases of national importance and sets binding precedents for all lower courts.
